Respectful critical evaluation

Evaluate the argument rather than the person.

Evaluate the argument rather than the person. Identify a strength, then a limitation or assumption needing support. May overlook and rests on help explain the concern.

Practical examples

The proposal is practical, but it may overlook seasonal demand.

المقترح عملي، لكنه قد يغفل الطلب الموسمي.

This conclusion rests on a relatively small sample.

يقوم هذا الاستنتاج على عينة صغيرة نسبيًا.

The argument would be stronger with a clearer comparison.

ستكون الحجة أقوى مع مقارنة أوضح.

Check your understanding

1. Which sentence critiques an argument professionally?
Continue learningSynthesising sources